What does fair look like when one person does almost all the caregiving?

A few of you asked me that after last week’s newsletter, when I wrote that being fair matters more than being equal. I’ve wondered the same thing about my cousin.

For eight years, she’s cared for her dad. She’s happy to do it. She’s also single, and somewhere along the way, her three siblings started assuming she’d handle everything.

Her siblings built careers, raised kids, and moved to other countries. My cousin had career plans of her own. To move ahead, she needed to live in another city. She stayed.

I often ask her, "What have you done for yourself lately?" While everyone in her family is grateful to her, I keep wondering what staying has cost her and what that means for her future.

If you're the one who stayed, who makes you whole?

This post:

UNDER THE HOOD
🔍What Caregiving Can Cost You

“I wish I could be of more help.”

Maybe you’ve heard that from a sibling and thought, “I wish you could be of more help too.” Then you hang up and ask your boss for Thursday afternoon off so you can take Dad to his appointment.

Most of us care for a parent out of love, obligation, or a little of both. You can be happy to do it and still wonder what it means for your own future.

Here are a few numbers to put it in perspective:

  • Women make up 60% to 66% of family caregivers. The average caregiver puts in 27 hours a week, close to a part-time job.

  • More than half of working caregivers go in late, leave early, or take time off. Almost 1 in 5 cut back to part-time, and nearly 1 in 10 stop working altogether.

  • AARP estimates the typical working caregiver loses about $120,500 in lifetime income. That includes missed pay, lower workplace retirement income, and smaller Social Security checks.

Here’s the irony: in some families, there’s money left to inherit because one sibling spent years providing care the family would otherwise have paid for. While her parents held on to their savings, she may have been putting less into her own.

If that’s your sister, what would help her now? If it’s you, what would you like your siblings to take on?

FRAMEWORK
🤝 What Fair Can Look Like

Want to know if your family’s setup is fair? Ask the person doing most of the care.

1.Give time, money, or a little of both.

There are really only two things any of us can give: time and money. Figure out who can do what. Maybe you can’t take Mom to her Thursday appointments, but you can pay for someone to spend Saturday mornings with her.

That might sound like, “Would it help if I covered Saturday mornings? I’ll find someone Mom likes and set it up.”

“Set it up” is the key part. If your sister still has to spend Friday calling agencies so she can be free Saturday morning…..

……that Saturday off just cost her Friday.

2. A sibling can bring up the money.

I get why the person caring for your parent might not want to ask about getting a bigger share of the inheritance. She loves them. She’s happy to be there. It’s a hard thing to bring up without worrying how it’ll sound.

If that’s your sister, and she’s comfortable with it, you could be the one to bring it up with Mom. “Mom, have you thought about paying [her name] for some of her time now, or recognizing those years in your will?”

Some parents may already have thought about it. Others may have written “equal shares” years ago, when they didn’t know how much care they’d need or who would help the most. Bringing it up gives your parent a chance to say what they want while they can still decide.

It also means your sister gets to be part of the conversation without having to make the case for herself.

If your parent wants to do either, an elder law or estate attorney can help set it up the right way.

3. Siblings can share what they inherit.

Even if Mom leaves everything equally, you don’t need a will to tell you who did the work.

Once you receive your inheritance, you can choose to give your sister part of your own share to recognize the years she spent caring for Mom. If you’re considering it, an estate attorney can walk you through the tax implications before money or property changes hands.

4. Keep score as a family.

I heard about one family that kept score so they could divide the inheritance fairly. Every task got points. Driving their mom to the doctor was 50. Getting Mom and her wheelchair into the car for an ice cream run was 25. A visit counted for 10 points an hour. Dealing with insurance provider was 30 points. When it came time to divide the inheritance, they added up the points and used the totals to help decide each person’s share.

I love that the ice cream run counted. The best part is sitting down together and agreeing on what counts while everyone still remembers what it took to get Mom out for ice cream.

If keeping score sounds a little cold, consider this: Japan wrote a version of it into law. Since 2019, a relative who cared for someone without pay, even a daughter-in-law caring for her husband’s parents, can ask the heirs to compensate her.

MINI ACTION
✅ One Question for Yourself

If you’re the caregiver, think about this: If this went on for five more years, what would you want to have protected for yourself?

Maybe it’s your job. Your retirement savings. Your health. One morning a week that’s just yours. Write down whatever comes up first. That’s the thing worth asking for help with.

If you’re the sibling who’s done less, ask yourself: What’s one thing I could take off her plate that she’d never ask me for? Then offer it, and set it up yourself.

I’ve spent years asking my cousin what she’s done for herself lately. The last time we talked about her future, I didn’t ask a question. I told her, “I got you. If things fail, I got you.”

Reply

Avatar

or to participate